data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/33854/33854a1712c5bbf42882b44eb0a2a6aeb360be81" alt=""
How often do we look at Bill Gates and admire his genius? Or wonder why Asians are so good at math? Why do lower-economic students fall behind wealthier ones? Why might pilots from countries with a high "power distance" index be more likely to crash a plane than pilots from a country with a low "power distance" index? Is being gifted with an IQ of 140 any different than having an IQ of 180--or can you be too gifted? How many hours do you have to practice or work to become great, whether it's the violin, computer programming, golf, or chess?
The sections on culture were especially interesting. If you have always lived within your own culture, even one that is more diverse like the US, you don't see your own culture. We may be able to articulate the values and customs, but rarely (if ever) do we think about how we respond to authority, how we answer questions, how we approach problems as a product of culture. It's only when our mores are thrown up against something different do we recognize that who we are and what we do are largely products of culture, family background, and circumstances beyond our control. I have worked with some very arrogant smug people who pat themselves on the back and say, "Look what I have accomplished through my hard work" and not comprehend that the "can do" attitudes, the ability to persevere, the work ethic, and the conditions surrounding that person from birth (and sometimes a generation or so back) play as much as part as the personal efforts of that person. The Outliers digs into those other things and serves as an important reminder that, whether a person is John D. Rockefeller or a convicted felon, multiple complex factors come into play to shape who we are.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a850d/a850d91cd9c1784efc982e0649ac4456dc0dbc05" alt=""
The premise of his new book is that America has to lead a new world-wide revolution regarding the environment and in our relationships with other countries. Post 9/11 we have withdrawn and are operating out of fear, which has damaged our image and relationships. I'm only into the first chapter, but I think it will be very good.
Both of these books might be considered "soft" by people who study foreign relations, environmental science, or economics seriously, but for those of us who are reasonably intelligent and well-read, but don't have the time or inclination to dive into those subjects in depth, these authors have presented information that is thought-provoking, a strong reminder to view information, people and events with a critical eye. In these weeks leading up to the Presiden't inauguration, we will hear about all the things Obama promises to do, what he needs to do, and why he can't possibly do it. There will be ample opportunities to think critically about what we hear and see.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/58d4b/58d4bf608dd3fc2fc04c5dbd54e5e083409b6880" alt=""
And, since I'm on a roll and mentioned it above, this is another one along the same lines. What do real estate agents and the Ku Klux Klan have in common? Why do drug dealers live with their mothers? Why are people still smoking? Again, Levitt takes perceptions or situations and looks at the conditions that create them. His chapter on the Chicago school system as it relates to teachers and students cheating on standardized tests is fascinating for anyone in education or who cares about education reform. Humorous and accessible, while still being a very smart read.
Happy reading!
No comments:
Post a Comment